Usually, I want the government to stay out of education, but House Bill 1149 is something I could get behind, extending mandatory recess up to eighth grade! Absolutely! Yes, please do! That is if the bill isn’t pork rolled with extra nonsense. As of writing this, the bill currently does not have any unrelated funding or provisions, so I see no reason it shouldn’t pass. And it is so important for developing brains to have free play.
I started my teaching career in middle school. Those three years were a nightmare wrapped in an amazing experience. However, I noticed these kids are overworked more than millennials and older generations were. The schools test students at an insane rate. Most of these kids are taking high school level math classes in 6th grade. Some students have six classes, and extracurriculars, sports, and Florida Virtual School (FLVS) classes so they don’t have to take certain ones in high school. Students in seventh grade were also remotely completing eighth grade simultaneously. These kids need a break. Their parents, teachers, and the school board are pushing them to a breaking point. We forget that middle school students are still children. They are not borderline young adults like those in their junior and senior years of high school.
The first post I saw about this was littered with comments. So many people were saying isn’t this what P.E. is for? No, no, it’s not. P.E. is a class where students are still in a structured learning environment. It may be an athletic class, but there are still requirements that students must follow. And after seeing the comments, it’s obvious that the general public is blissfully unaware that most middle school students do not have P.E. at all. Many students who would be in a P.E. class are in intensive reading or other classes instead to help boost their grades and standardized test scores.
Another argument from those who have never taught or haven’t been in a school setting in recent years brought up lunch. They argued that this was a time for students to be social. However, with so many students in the public school system, most barely get through the line and have enough time to eat. And each school has a different way of handling lunch. Some schools allow students to sit wherever they would like in the cafeteria, while others will allow students to go outside or to the media center. But there are still some schools that require students to sit with their class. This leaves little time for students to decompress and be social because of the restrictions put in place.
One of the dumbest arguments people had for not implementing recess for middle students was that they would be on their phones. My answer to that is so what?! I am 99% certain that the adults complaining about kids escaping into their phones during breaks would do the same thing. People think playground when they think of recess. But recess is a time when children may do whatever they want. They can read, draw, talk to friends without worrying about being told they are too loud, or they can watch stupid videos on their phone and just be. It shouldn’t matter what they are doing with their time as long as they are outside and not being jerks to one another. Recess would be the only time in their day where they aren’t being told what to do.
Many adults take this for granted. We go to work, but before and after work we are in control of our own lives, whatever that may look like. Children do not. If the students are in clubs or sports they are still being told what to do by adults. Yes, they may enjoy what they are doing, but it isn’t freedom of choice. When they get home, children also have their own responsibilities, be it chores or homework. But recess, this twenty minutes of supervised, unstructured free play is solely for being social. After students go home, it’s harder for students to see their friends. Some might live far away or have limited screen time with their phones or computers. But during recess, they are free to communicate with their friends in a way no classroom, including P.E. and lunch, will allow them.
House Bill 1149 plans to allow a minimum of 20 consecutive minutes per day. Honestly, I am not sure how they would implement that. Most schools have their days structured with six 50-minute classes. It wouldn’t be wise to go any shorter than that. The schools could return to block scheduling, where classes are longer, allowing time for recess to be added to the schedule. Thankfully, this decision is above my pay grade.
After I read this bill, I discussed with my freshmen how they would have felt having recess in middle school, and every single one of them said yes. Most claimed that they felt more burnout in middle school than they do in high school. At some of the middle schools in our area, they would have Fun Wednesday or Friday mornings with music and dancing in the courtyard. Sometimes they would have pep rallies at the end of the day. But they said if they had to pick from the two, it would have been a fun morning because they had a choice of where to go and what to do. However, if they could have had a midday break, that would have been better. Just time to stop and not feel the pressure of the day. Some said they would catch up on homework; one kid said he would take a nap, while others said they wanted to play basketball with friends who couldn’t have a PE class. One girl said she wanted to jam out with her band friends because they never have the chance to play the music they wanted.
So to the adults making the decision in Tallahassee, please let’s do this. The kids need it. They want it. And what is so strange is that education keeps forgetting we’re here for the kids. We are here to make them better, and sometimes a break is what they need to do better and focus on who to be shaped into better students and, one day, members of society.


